首页 500强 活动 榜单 商业 科技 商潮 专题 品牌中心
杂志订阅

法国最新债务预警:治理日益失灵,连“太少、太晚”的改革都举步维艰

Jason Ma
2026-10-28

穆迪表示:“2027年预算进程正赶上法国多年来规模最大的社会抗议浪潮。”

文本设置
小号
默认
大号
Plus(0条)

2026年10月17日,一名抗议者在巴黎共和广场手持烟雾弹和法国国旗,参与反对“高昂生活成本"的示威活动。图片来源:Kiran RIDLEY / AFP via Getty Images

尽管法国躲过了穆迪的信用评级下调,但这家评级机构对欧元区第二大经济体的描绘仍然相当黯淡,凸显了该国棘手的政治局面带来的风险。

在上周五发布的公告中,穆迪将法国维持在Aa3评级——比美国低两级,比德国低三级——展望为负面;而惠誉和标准普尔全球两家同行给出的评级还要再低一档。

据穆迪称,法国仍拥有富裕的经济和称职的公共机构,但政治格局可能使政府陷入瘫痪,从而无法采取痛苦的减赤举措。

报告特别指出了法国分裂的议会——议会经常与政府唱反调——以及政治和社会的不稳定。一个多月以来,法国各地不断上演抗议活动,上周末更是演变成大规模骚乱。

最初,学生们抗议公共教育投入不足,随后,其他人也加入进来,反对因美国对伊朗战争导致燃料价格飙升而带来的高昂生活成本。其他欧洲国家也出现了类似的抗议活动,被称为“10月17日运动”。

与此同时,法国迫在眉睫的债务危机已使债券收益率升至24年来的最高水平,闪回了2011年欧元区债务危机以来未见的预警信号。法国公共债务如今已经达到创纪录的4万亿美元,占GDP的119%——这是自二战结束以来的最高比率。

随着极右翼和极左翼候选人在明年春天的法国总统大选中领先,对于任何一方是否会采取必要艰难举措来恢复财政秩序这件事,市场已经失去了信心。

一份2027年预算提案已摆上台面,拟将财政赤字从5.4%适度降至GDP的5%,但由于政治陷入僵局,该预算尚未通过。穆迪警告称,近期社会动荡可能制约整饬财政的努力。

穆迪表示:“2027年预算进程正赶上法国多年来规模最大的社会抗议浪潮。”

穆迪预计预算最终会被批准,但可能是以法令形式通过,因为国民议会仍在犹豫不决。即便如此,预算的实际执行力度可能也不如预期,赤字将仅降至GDP的5.2%——原因是GDP增速将低于政府预测,且实施真正的支出削减面临政治阻力。

这份太少、太晚的预算并不会终结法国的债务困境。穆迪表示,要想在总统大选之后稳定债务负担,需要“重大且持续的财政努力”,而债务负担明年预计将达到GDP的122%。该评级机构对法国领导人能否迎接这一挑战并不抱信心。

“虽然我们预计下一任总统和政府将继续努力缩减法国的赤字,但我们的基准预期是:鉴于社会紧张局势、可能持续分裂的政治环境以及疲软的GDP增长,他们不太可能实施快速的财政整固,穆迪预测道。”因此,债务负担在当前十年的剩余时间里将继续上升。

好在还有一点时间——穆迪指出,法国债务的平均期限约为8.5年。这意味着,近期借贷成本的大幅上升必须持续相当长的时间,才会实质性恶化债务的可负担性。

但穆迪补充说,法国尤其容易受到由地缘政治以及国内政治动荡所驱动的“事件型风险”的冲击,并表示立法者在当前局面下将难以解决最紧迫的问题。

报告称:“负面展望反映出,法国政治格局的分裂将持续影响国家立法机构正常运转,这一风险仍在上升。”

“这种政治不稳定在当前的社会紧张局势中也清晰可见。它有可能削弱法国政府应对关键政策挑战的能力,例如高企的财政赤字、不断上升的债务负担、以及借贷成本的持续增加,致使主权国家关键信用指标的恶化速度比我们目前的预期还要快。”

麦格理(Macquarie)的全球策略师蒂埃里·威斯曼(Thierry Wizman)和加雷思·贝里(Gareth Berry)也将法国债务危机与抗议活动联系起来。

在本月早些时候的一份报告中,他们警告说,抗议持续的时间越长,政府就越有可能屈服并批准更多支出,而这将使债务状况进一步恶化。

那将推高法国债券的收益率,使为这类支出融资的借贷变得更加昂贵——从而加剧骚乱者所抱怨的问题。

他们写道:“由于政治极化,法国正滑向一场全面的公民危机——此前,这种极化主要体现在政治领域本身,仅限于投票箱内。我们认为,法国债务收益率的上升与过去几天的街头骚乱并非孤立事件,两者之间存在直接的、自我强化的因果关系链。”(财富中文网

译者:珠珠

尽管法国躲过了穆迪的信用评级下调,但这家评级机构对欧元区第二大经济体的描绘仍然相当黯淡,凸显了该国棘手的政治局面带来的风险。

在上周五发布的公告中,穆迪将法国维持在Aa3评级——比美国低两级,比德国低三级——展望为负面;而惠誉和标准普尔全球两家同行给出的评级还要再低一档。

据穆迪称,法国仍拥有富裕的经济和称职的公共机构,但政治格局可能使政府陷入瘫痪,从而无法采取痛苦的减赤举措。

报告特别指出了法国分裂的议会——议会经常与政府唱反调——以及政治和社会的不稳定。一个多月以来,法国各地不断上演抗议活动,上周末更是演变成大规模骚乱。

最初,学生们抗议公共教育投入不足,随后,其他人也加入进来,反对因美国对伊朗战争导致燃料价格飙升而带来的高昂生活成本。其他欧洲国家也出现了类似的抗议活动,被称为“10月17日运动”。

与此同时,法国迫在眉睫的债务危机已使债券收益率升至24年来的最高水平,闪回了2011年欧元区债务危机以来未见的预警信号。法国公共债务如今已经达到创纪录的4万亿美元,占GDP的119%——这是自二战结束以来的最高比率。

随着极右翼和极左翼候选人在明年春天的法国总统大选中领先,对于任何一方是否会采取必要艰难举措来恢复财政秩序这件事,市场已经失去了信心。

一份2027年预算提案已摆上台面,拟将财政赤字从5.4%适度降至GDP的5%,但由于政治陷入僵局,该预算尚未通过。穆迪警告称,近期社会动荡可能制约整饬财政的努力。

穆迪表示:“2027年预算进程正赶上法国多年来规模最大的社会抗议浪潮。”

穆迪预计预算最终会被批准,但可能是以法令形式通过,因为国民议会仍在犹豫不决。即便如此,预算的实际执行力度可能也不如预期,赤字将仅降至GDP的5.2%——原因是GDP增速将低于政府预测,且实施真正的支出削减面临政治阻力。

这份太少、太晚的预算并不会终结法国的债务困境。穆迪表示,要想在总统大选之后稳定债务负担,需要“重大且持续的财政努力”,而债务负担明年预计将达到GDP的122%。该评级机构对法国领导人能否迎接这一挑战并不抱信心。

“虽然我们预计下一任总统和政府将继续努力缩减法国的赤字,但我们的基准预期是:鉴于社会紧张局势、可能持续分裂的政治环境以及疲软的GDP增长,他们不太可能实施快速的财政整固,穆迪预测道。”因此,债务负担在当前十年的剩余时间里将继续上升。

好在还有一点时间——穆迪指出,法国债务的平均期限约为8.5年。这意味着,近期借贷成本的大幅上升必须持续相当长的时间,才会实质性恶化债务的可负担性。

但穆迪补充说,法国尤其容易受到由地缘政治以及国内政治动荡所驱动的"事件型风险"的冲击,并表示立法者在当前局面下将难以解决最紧迫的问题。

报告称:“负面展望反映出,法国政治格局的分裂将持续影响国家立法机构正常运转,这一风险仍在上升。”

“这种政治不稳定在当前的社会紧张局势中也清晰可见。它有可能削弱法国政府应对关键政策挑战的能力,例如高企的财政赤字、不断上升的债务负担、以及借贷成本的持续增加,致使主权国家关键信用指标的恶化速度比我们目前的预期还要快。”

麦格理(Macquarie)的全球策略师蒂埃里·威斯曼(Thierry Wizman)和加雷思·贝里(Gareth Berry)也将法国债务危机与抗议活动联系起来。

在本月早些时候的一份报告中,他们警告说,抗议持续的时间越长,政府就越有可能屈服并批准更多支出,而这将使债务状况进一步恶化。

那将推高法国债券的收益率,使为这类支出融资的借贷变得更加昂贵——从而加剧骚乱者所抱怨的问题。

他们写道:“由于政治极化,法国正滑向一场全面的公民危机——此前,这种极化主要体现在政治领域本身,仅限于投票箱内。我们认为,法国债务收益率的上升与过去几天的街头骚乱并非孤立事件,两者之间存在直接的、自我强化的因果关系链。”(财富中文网)

译者:珠珠

France avoided a credit downgrade from Moody’s, but the ratings agency painted a bleak picture of the eurozone’s second-largest economy that highlighted the risks from its intractable politics.

In an announcement late Friday, Moody’s kept France at Aa3—two grades below the U.S. and three below Germany—with a negative outlook, while ratings from peers Fitch and S&P Global are one notch lower.

France still boasts a wealthy economy and competent public institutions, according to Moody’s, but the political landscape threatens to paralyze the government and prevent it from making painful deficit-reduction steps.

The report flagged France’s divided parliament, which is often at odds with the government, as well as political and social instability. For over a month, the country has been consumed by protests that erupted into widespread riots last weekend.

At first, students decried the lack of investment in public education, then others joined in to speak out against the high cost of living as fuel prices soar due to the U.S. war on Iran. Other European countries have seen similar protests in what’s been dubbed the “Oct. 17 Movement.”

At the same time, France’s looming debt has sent bond yields to the highest levels in 24 years, flashing warning signs not seen since the eurozone debt crisis in 2011. France’s public debt is now a record $4 trillion, or 119% of GDP—the highest ratio since the immediate aftermath of World War II.

With far-right and far-left candidates in the lead to become France’s next president in the spring, markets are losing confidence that either side will take the difficult steps necessary to restore fiscal order.

A 2027 budget proposal that would modestly bring the deficit down to 5% of GDP from 5.4% is now on the table but has yet to pass amid political gridlock, and Moody’s warned recent unrest could constrain fiscal consolidation efforts.

“The 2027 budget process coincides with some of the most extensive social protests France has experienced in many years,” it said.

Moody’s expects the budget will eventually be adopted, but possibly by decree as the National Assembly dithers. And even then, the budget will likely do less than hoped, reducing the deficit to 5.2% of GDP due to weaker GDP growth than projected by the government and the political challenges of implementing real spending cuts.

This too-little, too-late budget will not be the end of France’s debt woes. Moody’s said a “significant and sustained fiscal effort” is required beyond the presidential elections to stabilize the debt burden, which is on track to hit 122% next year. The ratings agency isn’t confident France’s leaders will meet the challenge.

“While we expect that the next president and government will seek to continue to narrow France’s deficit, our baseline expectation is that they are unlikely to be able to implement rapid fiscal consolidation in light of social tensions, a political environment that is likely to remain fragmented and muted GDP growth,” it predicted. “As a result, the debt burden will continue to rise through the remainder of the decade.”

There is still some time, as Moody’s pointed out that the average maturity of France’s debt is around 8.5 years. That means the recent surge in borrowing costs must be sustained over an extended period to meaningfully worsen debt affordability.

But France is especially vulnerable to “event risk” driven by geopolitics as well as domestic politics and instability, Moody’s added, describing a situation where lawmakers will have trouble tacking the most pressing problems.

“The negative outlook reflects the increased risk that the fragmentation of France’s political landscape will continue to impair the functioning of the country’s legislative institutions,” the report said.

“This political instability, also visible in the current social tensions, risks hampering the French government’s ability to address key policy challenges such as an elevated fiscal deficit, rising debt burden, and durable increase in borrowing costs, thus leading to a more rapid weakening in the sovereign’s key credit metrics than we currently expect.”

Thierry Wizman and Gareth Berry, global strategists at Macquarie, also drew a connection between the French debt crisis and the protests.

In a note earlier this month, they warned that the longer the protest go on, the more likely it is that the government will cave and approve more spending, which would make the debt situation worse.

That would drive up yields on French bonds, making borrowing to fund that spending even more expensive—and thus worsen the problem that the rioters are complaining about.

“France is veering toward a full-blown civil crisis because of its political polarization, which heretofore had been manifested mainly in the political realm itself, and at the ballot box only,” they wrote. “And rather than being isolated events, we think a direct and self-reinforcing causal connection can be drawn between the rise in France’s debt yields and the street riots of the past few days.”

财富中文网所刊载内容之知识产权为财富媒体知识产权有限公司及/或相关权利人专属所有或持有。未经许可,禁止进行转载、摘编、复制及建立镜像等任何使用。
0条Plus
精彩评论
评论

撰写或查看更多评论

请打开财富Plus APP

前往打开