订阅

多平台阅读

微信订阅

杂志

申请纸刊赠阅

订阅每日电邮

移动应用

专栏 - 财富书签

反脆弱性:混乱让我们更坚强

Scott Cendrowski 2012年12月19日

《财富》书签(Weekly Read)专栏专门刊载《财富》杂志(Fortune)编辑团队的书评,解读商界及其他领域的新书。我们每周都会选登一篇新的评论。
纳西姆·塔勒布在其最近出版的著作中,盛赞压力和混乱的正面作用。脆弱的事物面临压力时倾向崩溃。但是,现实世界还有不少事物会在压力作用下变得更加强壮。比如,去健身房练举重会让一个人的肌肉更加有力。再比如病菌能增强我们的免疫系统。

    为什么瑞士是有史以来最稳定的国家?与其他国家不同的是,瑞士货币币值自危机以来持续走高,而瑞士并没有强大的中央银行来支撑这一切。就这点来说,上述功劳似与中央政府关系不大。在《反脆弱性:无序的收获》(Antifragile: Things That Gain From Disorder)一书中,纳西姆·塔勒布戏谑地写道,比起自己国家总统的名字,瑞士的老百姓们反倒更熟悉法国总统和美国总统的名字。

    瑞士是塔勒布有关反脆弱性理论的最好例证——在打击和混乱的作用下,特定事物会变得更加坚强,而脆弱的事物则直接败下阵来。

    塔勒布认为,瑞士之所以是稳定的样板,正是因为它没有强大的中央银行或政府。组成瑞士的十几个拥有主权的州彼此之间争吵不断,斗争不休。这种混乱局面却让瑞士变得更加坚强,小问题在演变成大危机(比如财政悬崖)之前就已经得以解决。

    期货交易员出身的思想家塔勒布将《反脆弱性》一书视为毕生杰作,书中所讲的不过是一个被今人遗忘的老道理。脆弱的事物,例如大银行和负债的消费者,面临压力时倾向崩溃。但是,现实世界还有不少事物会在压力作用下变得更加强壮。去健身房练举重会让一个人的肌肉更加有力。病菌能加强我们的免疫系统。尽管颇受非议,《五十度灰》(Fifty Shades of Grey)一书的销量却一路扶摇而上。

    让塔勒布恼火的是,当前的领导人正带领着这个世界向着反脆弱性的反方向前进。于是,在小问题面前,我们的经济和社会变得脆弱不堪。无论五家大到不能倒的巨型银行犯的错有多大,金融系统还要依靠它们。我们的中央银行为了短期表现刺激经济,而对刺激政策会给未来十年经济带来的影响却一无所知。为了避免冲击现有的银行和经济——即所谓经济的自然周期——实际上,我们两者都损害了。“为避免犯小错,而大错特错,”塔勒布写道。

    How did Switzerland become the most stable country in history? Its currency, unlike ours, keeps hitting new highs post-crisis, yet Switzerland doesn't have a large central bank working behind the scenes. For that matter, it doesn't have much of a central government. In Antifragile: Things That Gain From Disorder, Nassim Taleb jokes that the average Swiss citizen can name the presidents of France and the United States before they can name their own.

    It turns out Switzerland perfectly captures Taleb's idea of antifragility -- the concept that certain things grow stronger with shock and turmoil, as opposed to fragile things, which just break down.

    Taleb argues that Switzerland is a model of stability precisely because it doesn't have a big central bank or national government. Instead, its dozens of sovereign mini-states squabble and fight constantly. This turmoil actually makes the country stronger because the Swiss get small problems out of the way before they can metastasize into something bigger like, say, a fiscal cliff.

    What Taleb introduces in Antifragile -- a book the brash options-trader-turned-philosopher calls his life's work -- is an old concept that seems to have been forgotten today. Fragile things, such as big banks or debt-laden consumers, tend to break under stress. But the world is full of things that grow stronger when exposed to stress. Your muscles get stronger when you lift weights at the gym. Immune systems strengthen from exposure to germs. Fifty Shades of Grey sales soar despite critical disdain.

    What riles Taleb is that our leaders have increasingly shifted the modern world in the opposite direction of antifragility. As a result, our economy and society are vulnerable to little shocks. The financial system is dependent on five large banks that are too-big-to-fail, no matter how big their mistakes. Our central bankers juice the economy for short-term gain without knowing how they're affecting the next decade. By avoiding shocks to our banks and economy -- AKA the natural business cycle -- we actually harm both. "Avoiding small mistakes makes the big ones more severe," Taleb writes.

我来点评

  最新文章

最新文章:

中国煤业大迁徙

500强情报中心

财富专栏